There was a lot to enjoy for investors in ServiceTitan’s (TTAN) most recent earnings release.
Revenue also topped Wall Street estimates. Profit above forecasts. Free cash flow up about 50%. The software company’s main product based on artificial intelligence was adopted faster than the company’s management anticipated.
The move wiped off about a third of its worth among investors.
ServiceTitan stock plunged 30% Wednesday after management forecast fiscal third-quarter revenue of $285 million to $287 million, below the roughly $288 million Wall Street expected. The selloff followed a more than 19% drop in after-hours trading immediately after the report.
The miss itself was minor in guiding terms.
Even more troubling for ServiceTitan, its growth is decelerating at a time when investors are becoming less tolerant of software businesses being challenged by AI.
But there is a caveat.
Part of Service Titan’s short-term revenue headwinds are coming from higher adoption of its own AI product, Max. Management anticipates the transformation to result in a temporary revenue impact of $4 million to $5 million.
That means ServiceTitan now needs to show something uncommon to investors: that one reason its growth seems worse now might make its firm more valuable tomorrow.
ServiceTitan’s numbers don’t look like a business in trouble
ServiceTitan’s second quarter earnings were far better than the market response indicated.
Revenue increased 21% to $292.8 million, beating the $285.9 million analysts expected. Adjusted earnings of 40 cents a share topped expectations of 35 cents.
Platform revenue was up 22 percent to $284.5 million.
More significantly, ServiceTitan is becoming much more lucrative as it expands.
Non-GAAP operating income grew 52% to $44.4 million, and the adjusted operating margin improved to 15.2% from 12.1%. Operating losses on a GAAP basis were $27.6 million vs. $34.8 million.
Related: AI data center backlash accelerates ahead of elections
Cash generation improved further.
Operating cash flow jumped to $58 million from $40.3 million. Non-GAAP free cash flow rose 47% to $50.5 million.
Net dollar retention also stayed over 110%.
There was one significant caution.
Gross transaction volume, the value billed to consumers on ServiceTitan, climbed 17% to $26.8 billion. But that growth rate was down from 19% a year ago.
Revenue growth also decelerated to 21% from 25%, while platform revenue growth decreased to 22% from 26%.
ServiceTitan is still growing. Wall Street is worried about how quickly that growth is slowing.
ServiceTitan’s AI success comes with a surprising cost
Here is when Max alters the tale.
Contractors use ServiceTitan, a “Agentic Operating System” for the trades, to manage customer acquisition, scheduling, dispatching, payments, and operations.
Max encapsulates its aim to automate more of those activities using AI.
And consumers are embracing it quicker than ServiceTitan had anticipated.
The company said it exceeded its goal of doubling Max locations during the second quarter. Management now expects more than 700 enrolled Max locations by the end of the fiscal year.
But getting clients onboard Max poses a funny accounting dilemma.
ServiceTitan generally recognizes its primary subscription income ratably during the term of a contract. Max is different since consumers need time to modify processes and install the solution.
That implies charging grows gradually.
ServiceTitan is also eliminating certain onboarding costs for current clients upgrading to Max.
Management expects the combined impact of those measures to trim revenue by around $4 million to $5 million for the balance of the fiscal year.
That’s not enough to explain every concern behind a 30% stock collapse. But it changes what investors should be watching. ServiceTitan isn’t struggling to persuade customers to try its newest AI product.
Its challenge is to prove that a speedier adoption would ultimately provide sufficient extra customer value to make up for the income it is foregoing during the shift.
Wall Street isn’t giving ServiceTitan much room for error
That evidence is becoming more significant with ServiceTitan’s third-quarter outlook. The company predicts sales of $285 million to $287 million, compared with $292.8 million in the second quarter.
Adjusted operating income is estimated to decline to between $29 million and $30 million from $44.4 million.
But the picture for the whole year is not that scary.
ServiceTitan expects fiscal 2027 revenue of $1.139 billion to $1.144 billion and non-GAAP operating income of $152 million to $154 million.
The corporation is therefore not predicting a collapse. It’s anticipating a difficult shift.
More AI:
- Nvidia just made a move Wall Street wasn’t ready for
- Microsoft just took sides in AI policy fight
- OpenAI just disclosed something genuinely alarming
There’s another reason investors should be suspicious. AI is an emerging cause of fear throughout the software business as ever-more-capable models threaten to automate operations formerly performed by specialized applications.
Those fears hit software stocks again this week.
ServiceTitan is arguing that AI will strengthen rather than replace its platform.
CEO Ara Mahdessian called delivering an agentic operating system to the trades and using AI internally “once in a lifetime opportunities.”
ServiceTitan’s 700-location AI test now matters more than earnings
The 30% selloff gives investors two opposing interpretations.
Looking at ServiceTitan’s Q2 financial results, the pessimistic argument begins with three numbers: Revenue growth decelerated from 25% to 21%, platform growth slowed from 26% to 22%, and GTV growth slowed from 19% to 17%.
If these trends continue, a small miss on expectations could lead to a larger decline.
The bullish case begins elsewhere.
ServiceTitan put up record free cash flow, boosted its adjusted operating margins by over three percentage points, and beat its own Max adoption goal.
That makes 700 likely the most relevant figure in the study.
If ServiceTitan concludes the year with more than 700 Max locations and those customers eventually spend more, stay longer, and run more effectively, the immediate revenue loss might prove to be just that, transitory.
Otherwise, investors would face a slower-growing software firm that spends substantially on an AI transformation that doesn’t enhance its economics.
And ServiceTitan exceeded profits but lost about a third of its market value because Wall Street isn’t ready to wait forever for that answer.
Now the business needs to convince the market that the contradiction this quarter between slowing reported growth and growing AI take-up is the expense of developing its new growth engine and not a sign the old one is running out of gas.
