Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Central bankers need to dial down their rhetoric


THE recent firehose of opinions spilling forth from officials at the Federal Reserve, European Central Bank (ECB), and Bank of England (BoE) has been as unedifying as it is unhelpful. Given the febrile state of financial markets and the collective failure of the economic community to clear even its own low bar when it comes to pretending to see the future, policymakers would be advised to pipe down.

Following the post-pandemic surge in inflation, there’s been a collective consensus to move away from explicit forward guidance on monetary policy, replaced by a meeting-by-meeting data-dependent outlook. That’s a practical approach to a highly uncertain economic backdrop, and is to be welcomed. But it is falling apart, and is having the unwelcome side-effect of making fixed-income markets more volatile (albeit exacerbated in recent days after the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank), something policymakers should know to avoid.

My colleague Mohamed El-Erian took direct aim at Fed Chair Jerome Powell on Wednesday for the bluntness in his opening statement at the semiannual congressional testimony. Powell revived the prospect of a 50 basis-point hike at the next Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting on March 22. That’s a head-spinning shift after the US central bank downscaled to just a quarter-point raise at its last meeting on Jan. 31. Powell was forced to add a big “if” at Thursday’s repeat testimony, emphasizing that nothing is decided until February’s inflation and payroll reports are scrutinized. That’s as it should be; data, not Fed testimony, should set the tone.

Moreover, the FOMC makes a collective decision on policy, and while individual views are part of the process, regional Fed presidents should not dominate. Instead, vocal hawks such as St. Louis Fed President James Bullard (a non-voter this year) and Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari (voter) are stealing much of the oxygen in airing their particular opinions. If policymakers have new insights to add on a specific economic approach, then let’s hear from them — but not if it is to bang the drum of their latest hot take on where interest rates should be. That is for the collective decision-making forum of the central bank, not for mass broadcast.

This is far from just a Fed problem. Following calls for an additional 200 basis points of tightening from Austrian central bank chief Robert Holzmann last week, Bank of Italy Governor Ignazio Visco made his displeasure clear. “Uncertainty is so high that the Governing Council of the ECB has agreed to decide ‘meeting by meeting,’ without ‘forward guidance,’” he said. “I therefore don’t appreciate statements by my colleagues about future and prolonged interest rate hikes.”

We hear from President Christine Lagarde at the post-meeting press conferences, and from Chief Economist Philip Lane if there is an important qualification on ECB policy. While national central bank chiefs should be free to opine on the state of the economy in their respective countries, and occasionally on the broader picture, setting interest-rate policy across 20 nations is all about the art of the compromise. What might seem necessary for Austria might not be the case elsewhere across the euro zone. Persistent calls for higher and longer rate hikes from such influential ECB policymakers as Bundesbank President Joachim Nagel make an already difficult task almost impossible.

The BoE is also struggling with policymakers having wildly divergent views. Two external members of the nine-person Monetary Policy Committee, Swati Dhingra and Silvana Tenreyro, voted for no change at the last two meetings when rates were raised by 50 basis points. A third outside member, Catherine Mann, has been calling for even faster hikes. Her comments on the risks posed by the potential for further weakness of the pound stray into an area which central bankers normally avoid, for good reason: Discussing currency values opens a political can of worms.

By contrast, we hear only infrequently from the Bank of Japan policy board — limited to just a four speeches last month — so when the governor does speak it carries more weight. Moreover, comments are usually couched in language designed to reveal little, as central banking should not be all revealing. Steering the economy requires subtlety and nuance.

The current torrent of rhetoric is enough to make me yearn for the opaqueness of former Fed Chair Alan Greenspan. Discretion is a useful tool in the central bank armory; it should be more valued. Some things are better kept within a committee which makes collective decisions, rather than aired for all to dissect. Less really is more sometimes.


Your information is secure and your privacy is protected. By opting in you agree to receive emails from us. Remember that you can opt-out any time, we hate spam too!



SM Investments Corp. announces annual stockholders’ meeting on April 26 – BusinessWorld Online ...


AyalaLand Logistics Holdings Corp. to conduct annual meeting of stockholders virtually on April 19 – BusinessWorld Online ...


The National Grid Corp. of the Philippines (NGCP) warned of possible power outages as temperatures sizzle in Metro Manila. — PHILIPPINE STAR/MICHAEL VARCAS THE...


A worker makes denim jeans for export at a garment factory in Manila, June 17, 2008. — REUTERS/ROMEO RANOCO By Luisa Maria Jacinta C....


PHILIPPINE STAR/WALTER BOLLOZOS By Keisha B. Ta-asan, Reporter THE PHILIPPINE economy is likely to expand by 5.8% this year, although elevated inflation and higher...


BW FILE PHOTO THE PHILIPPINE central bank is expected to raise benchmark rates by 25 basis points (bps) in May, which could mark the...

You May Also Like


COVID-19 has had a significant impact on the mental health of Filipinos across different groups all over the archipelago. From frontline workers, parents balancing...


REUTERS By Luz Wendy T. Noble, Reporter The country’s foreign exchange buffers slightly increased as of end-October as the value of the central bank’s...


BW FILE PHOTO GROSS BORROWINGS by the National Government reached P2.6 trillion as of end-September as it continued to raise funds to respond to...


KARASOLAR.COM TENA, Ecuador — Ecuador’s rainforest Achuar people say their ancestors long dreamed of a “fire canoe” or “electric fish” that would let them...

Disclaimer: Respect, its managers, its employees, and assigns (collectively "The Company") do not make any guarantee or warranty about what is advertised above. Information provided by this website is for research purposes only and should not be considered as personalized financial advice. The Company is not affiliated with, nor does it receive compensation from, any specific security. The Company is not registered or licensed by any governing body in any jurisdiction to give investing advice or provide investment recommendation. Any investments recommended here should be taken into consideration only after consulting with your investment advisor and after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company.

Copyright © 2022 Respect Investment. All Rights Reserved.