The after-dinner routine used to follow a script. You turned on the TV, someone opened Netflix, and the household argued over what to watch.
Now Americans spend more TV time on YouTube than with any other media company, according to Nielsen.
As noted by Seeking Alpha, HSBC downgraded Netflix Inc. (NFLX) to Hold from Buy on Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, and cut its price target by 21% to $76 from $96.
The message is blunt: YouTube is taking Netflix’s viewers, and HSBC does not expect them to return soon.
Analyst Mohammed Khallouf wrote that YouTube “has been rapidly expanding its living-room footprint,” in what Bloomberg called Netflix’s second downgrade in less than a week.
YouTube is winning the living room on Netflix’s time
YouTube, owned by Alphabet Inc. (GOOGL), captured a record 14.2% of U.S. TV viewing in July, according to Nielsen. Netflix moved the other way, sliding to 7.8%, according to TheWrap.
A year earlier, Netflix hit a record 8.8%, Nielsen reported. That is more than a tenth of its share gone in twelve months.
Engagement “drives retention, supports pricing power, and is closely followed by advertisers,” Khallouf wrote, according to Seeking Alpha. Advertising is where the gap gets expensive.
Related: Netflix stock has a strange stock price target problem
YouTube booked about $11.1 billion in ad revenue in the second quarter, reported CNBC. Netflix expects roughly $3 billion from ads for all of 2026, according to its shareholder letter. YouTube earns nearly four times that in a single quarter.
A recent Fortune report details how YouTube is paying to protect its lead, offering creators millions to keep videos exclusive for set periods. HSBC says that likely raises the cost of Netflix’s own creator push, according to Seeking Alpha.
Netflix is reporting less of what analysts now watch
The timing is awkward. In July, Netflix said its “What We Watched” engagement report would move to once a year starting in 2027, according to its shareholder letter. It wants investors focused on revenue and operating profit instead.
The same letter argued that “not all hours are equal.” That may be true, but Netflix no longer reports quarterly subscriber counts, according to TheWrap. Analysts are filling the gap with outside data, and that data is pointing downward.
More Netflix:
- Bill Ackman’s surprising $934 million bet after dumping Alphabet
- Bill Ackman does U-turn on Netflix, makes bold claim
- Netflix stock has a strange stock price target problem
HSBC found viewing hours for English-language shows in Netflix’s weekly Top 10 fell about 17% year over year in July and August, according to TipRanks.
Wells Fargo reached a similar verdict on Friday, Sept. 18, 2026, cutting Netflix to Underweight with a $57 target, according to StockAnalysis.
“Engagement trends look worrying to us,” analyst Steven Cahall wrote, according to The Hollywood Reporter.
Netflix stock is priced for doubt, not collapse
At about $300 billion in market value, according to StockAnalysis, Netflix sits inside the S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100 funds that fill many retirement accounts. Its slide reaches well beyond its own shareholders.
The stock opened at $73.69 on Tuesday, Sept. 22, and closed at $72.16, down 1.64%, according to StockAnalysis. Shares traded near $72.35 in Wednesday’s premarket session, per the same data.
The 52-week range of $65.08 to $124.86 leaves Netflix about 42% below its high and 11% above its low.
The 51 analysts polled by S&P Global still rate Netflix a Buy, with an average target of $92.93 that implies about 29% upside, according to StockAnalysis. Targets run from $57 at Wells Fargo to $135 at BMO Capital.
The mix is shifting, though. Hold ratings rose to 16 in September from 12 in April, while Strong Buys slipped to 27 from 29, according to StockAnalysis. Sentiment rarely breaks at once; it erodes, then surfaces in clusters like this week’s.
The bull case still rests on real numbers:
- Household reach is climbing. Evercore ISI lifted its target to $110 after surveys showed U.S. penetration at a multiyear high.
- The second half faces a brutal comparison. It laps the final season of “Stranger Things”, so some engagement decline was always expected.
- Buybacks hit a record. Netflix repurchased $4.7 billion of stock in the second quarter, according to its shareholder letter.
Attention, not subscribers, is streaming’s new scorecard
Netflix has climbed out of a hole like this before. The stock fell 51% in 2022, and 2026 is on pace to be its worst year since.
That recovery leaned on pricing levers, including a cheaper ad tier and a crackdown on password sharing.
This slump is different. YouTube competes for attention at a price of zero, and no price increase can win back an evening spent somewhere else.
The first streaming war was fought over subscribers. The next one is being fought over minutes, and YouTube is setting the price.
Netflix reports third-quarter results on Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2026, according to StockAnalysis, offering the first test of whether it can buy those minutes back.
Related: Evercore wants investors to buy tumbling streaming stock
